A recent decision in the High Court of Jakarta in an appeal case between Dewa, an Indonesian Band, and Aquarius Musikindo held that Dewa had breached their contract with Aquarius. The decision is interesting because even though the High Court held that there was a breach of contract, the High Court then went on to vary the contractual penalties that were to apply for that breach.
The case arose because Dewa entered into a contract with Aquarius that required them to do an album and then supply an additional four new songs to be included on a “Best of …” compilation to be released at a later date. Dewa completed the album but had failed to deliver the four additional songs. Dewa then signed another contract with EMI.
Aquarius sued for breach of contract and sort to have the terms of the original contract enforced. The terms of the original contract included a USD 1 million cash payment in the event of a breach by Dewa and a fine of USD 1,000 each day the breach of contract payment was late. The High Court found the relevant contracts to be legally valid. Presumably, this means that Dewa took legal advice before signing the contracts and presumably agreed to the terms.
However, the High Court held that the figures were too high and modified them accordingly. In holding that Dewa had breached their contract with Aquarius the High Court ordered Dewa to make a USD 200,000 cash payment to Aquarius and pay USD 20 for each day that the payment is late. The decision does not go into detail as to why the High Court held that the original contract terms were too tough and sort to reduce the penalty for the breach to very modest levels.
It was expected that Dewa would appeal and they did. However, a cassation request must be filed within 14 days of the decision being received by the relevant parties. It is unclear whether Dewa met the filing deadline. According to the lawyers for Aquarius, Dewa missed the filing date and as such no cassation can be entertained by the courts.
The decision indicates that the High Court of Jakarta is willing to vary contractual terms if the court deems them to be severe or unfair. This is possible even where the parties have taken legal advice in the period leading up to the signing of a contractual agreement and presumably are aware of their respective rights and obligations.
The decision was handed-down on 25 September 2008.
A recent decision in the High Court of Jakarta in an appeal case between Dewa, an Indonesian Band, and Aquarius Musikindo held that Dewa had breached their contract with Aquarius. The decision is interesting because even though the High Court held that there was a breach of contract, the High Court then went on to vary the contractual penalties that were to apply for that breach.
The case arose because Dewa entered into a contract with Aquarius that required them to do an album and then supply an additional four new songs to be included on a “Best of …” compilation to be released at a later date. Dewa completed the album but had failed to deliver the four additional songs. Dewa then signed another contract with EMI.
Aquarius sued for breach of contract and sort to have the terms of the original contract enforced. The terms of the original contract included a USD 1 million cash payment in the event of a breach by Dewa and a fine of USD 1,000 each day the breach of contract payment was late. The High Court found the relevant contracts to be legally valid. Presumably, this means that Dewa took legal advice before signing the contracts and presumably agreed to the terms.
However, the High Court held that the figures were too high and modified them accordingly. In holding that Dewa had breached their contract with Aquarius the High Court ordered Dewa to make a USD 200,000 cash payment to Aquarius and pay USD 20 for each day that the payment is late. The decision does not go into detail as to why the High Court held that the original contract terms were too tough and sort to reduce the penalty for the breach to very modest levels.
It was expected that Dewa would appeal and they did. However, a cassation request must be filed within 14 days of the decision being received by the relevant parties. It is unclear whether Dewa met the filing deadline. According to the lawyers for Aquarius, Dewa missed the filing date and as such no cassation can be entertained by the courts.
The decision indicates that the High Court of Jakarta is willing to vary contractual terms if the court deems them to be severe or unfair. This is possible even where the parties have taken legal advice in the period leading up to the signing of a contractual agreement and presumably are aware of their respective rights and obligations.
The decision was handed-down on 25 September 2008.